• Photobucket
  • Photobucket
  • Photobucket
  • Photobucket

Review: SongGenie & CoverScout 3

iTunes is the place where my organization attempts always seem to fall short, whether i’m looking to find the cover of Yellow Submarine, or finding the man who wrote Vienna. I never seem to have the stamina to complete more then a few songs. Equinux has solved our frustration by developing SongGenie and CoverScout, two applications that supercharge the iTunes organizing experience by turning a weekend project into a 10 minute task.

CS

The UI

The interface of these two applications are nearly identical, which is a dark, sleek-looking window. CoverScout uses Apple’s CoverFlow to browse album artwork, while SongGenie uses a TimeMachine’s interface to browse through songs (one of the few differences). Both of these applications are extremely easy to use which is one of the reasons why I enjoy it so much. To get song information for a particular track in SongGenie, you simply right click (control-click) the song and choose “Identify.” To get artwork for an album, you click “Search.” Nothing to it.

Screen shot 2010-02-11 at 11.13.42 PM

Speed

The speed and reliability of CoverScout and SongGenie is astounding. One of the most shocking finds with these two applications is the accuracy of CoverScout’s search feature. It always finds the perfect album cover. As for SongGenie, it has yet to find the wrong information for a song. Equinux has done a fantastic job with making both of these applications so exceptional.

Editor

In CoverScout, you are given a very neat tool that allows you to edit artwork you have downloaded for a specific album. This is a particularly helpful feature given that many album covers online have a some type of border. With this editor, you are given the option to crop, add a frame, change the color levels, zoom, and take a photo via iSight to insert your own artwork.

Screen shot 2010-02-11 at 11.11.32 PM

Decisions, Decisions

The price point of these applications is what detracts us. SongGenie is $29.95 ($44.95 Family) and CoverScout 3 is $39.95 ($59.95 Family). Since it is nearly impossible to use only one of these applications, the total cost for most would be $70. That price makes me wonder, “is it worth it?” Sadly, my answer is unclear as it depends on how large your library is. We’ll be blunt: the idea of selling these apps as separate is non-sensical, and to add insult to injury, the price of the applications combined becomes completely unreasonable. (i’ll add some bonus material) For $80 you can probably hire some high school student to go on Google and fill out the information manually. Sure, it may not be quicker, but at least you can help Tommy buy his first car. At the price currently charged by Equinux, you have to either be as OCD as Charlie or have created a library that is simply not usable via laziness. Whatever the case, after you see the price tag, you’ll probably learn to add the names the next time you add something to iTunes.

SongGenie and CoverScout are two separate applications that are really peanut-butter and jelly, by removing one, the other is incomplete; hence why this review is of both SongGenie and CoverScout. For most people, that price is way too much to spend for an easier way to get album artwork (compared to some other services and applications). For others, it is worth it. Our conclusion is that if you have neglected your iTunes library, didn’t use Gracenote, have switched computers, perhaps pirated a couple of songs or for whatever other reason – turned your iTunes library into something you’d let a five year-old organize, you might want this app. Otherwise, it will not be such a useful application.

Both applications are available from Equinux’s website located here.

Related Posts

Tags: , , , ,

Categories: Mac Apps, The Feed, TheMacFeed Reviews:

  • Eric
    It's suddenly not loading anything but one album, even though I have many songs & albums with missing and/or incomplete covers.
    Basically it's not finding anything in Itunes, even though all the preferences and songs are in there. Worked fine yesterday. Re-booted, but no help. anyone else having this issue?
  • I'd delete it via an application like AppZapper or CleanMyMac, then Re-install it. If that does not work, contact the developers.
  • edan
    cover scout is ssooooooo slow!!!
    is anyone else having this problem?
  • No, it is working pretty fast for me.
  • oracleguru
    Cover scout is useless...more like boy scout....and the underhanded way you need to but SongGenie too, outrageous! Useless if you have many Hindi and Enlish songs, so please be aware!
  • I am about to do the same thing! Just got the MacHeist bundle and am about to get Song Genie.

    It seems to work alright in the demo.
    I only wish these features were included in future versions of iTunes.
  • Michael Chan
    I purchased the MacHeist Nano bundle today motivated partly because of CoverScout. My lossy compression library is ~200GB. CoverScout was doing a good job filling holes in my more obscure cuts, so I decided to throw another $30 ($10 more than what I paid for all the apps in the nano bundle!!) at equinix for SongGenie to try and fingerprint the numerous recordings I have that are ambiguously titled.

    So far, it has worked perfectly on a couple one-off IDs, though my system is at a crawl as it indexes the entire library. We'll see, but happy so far.
blog comments powered by Disqus